The Guess Who - Wheatfield Soul

The Guess Who – Wheatfield Soul

90 / 100

This was the fourth album for the Canadian band The Guess Who, and here they move into psychedelic pop territory with new lead singer Burton Cummings.

Written by: Eric

ARTIST: The Guess Who
ALBUM: Wheatfield Soul
LABEL: Nimbus 9
YEAR: 1969
CD REISSUE: Discogs Reissue List


LINEUP: Randy Bachman – lead guitar, sitar, backing vocals * Burton Cummings – organ, lead vocals, piano, rhythm guitar, flute * Jim Kale – bass, backing vocals * Garry Peterson – drums, percussion, tabla, backing vocals

TRACK LISTING: 01 These Eyes * 02 Pink Wine Sparkles In The Glass * 03 I Found Her In A Star * 04 Friends Of Mine * 05 When You Touch Me * 06 A Wednesday In Your Garden * 07 Lightfoot * 08 Love And A Yellow Rose * 09 Maple Fudge * 10 We’re Coming To Dinner



In several ways ‘Wheatfield Soul’ represented a seismic shift for The Guess Who. Moving away from the garage rock of the previous three albums into psychedelic pop territory, it’s the first album without lead vocalist Chad Allen who was replaced by new boy Burton Cummings.

It was the first LP not recorded in Minneapolis, Minnesota, a city that played an important role in the Winnipeg based band’s early history. Produced by Jack Richardson at A&R Studios in New York, the album wasn’t a big hit but it unleashed what is truly one of the greatest singles of the 1960’s.

The Songs

A co-write between Randy Bachman and Burton Cummings, ‘These Eyes’ is heaven sent. Seriously, I’m not an emotional guy but on a chilly North Dakota hillside in 2000 I saw the band open their set with this tune and was almost brought to tears. From the beautiful electric piano melody to Cummings impassioned vocals and light orchestration, its pop perfection with a capital P.

Unfortunately the rest of the album is something of a mixed bag with the band clearly searching for a sound of its own. ‘Pink Wine Sparkles In The Glass’ references The Beatles and the Bee Gees but it’s ‘I Found Her In A Star’ with Bachman’s fuzzed-out guitar that set the synapses alight and in my opinion this would have made for a great single.

At the time Cummings was a big Jim Morrison fan and the weird ‘Friends Of Mine’ sounds very much like The Doors with even more Beatles references and running way too long at 10 minutes. Wacky stuff and not their finest moment although I like the sweet jazzy pop of ‘A Wednesday In Your Garden’ while the Gordon Lightfoot tribute ‘Lightfoot’ sounds just like the man.

Sitar, Tabla and medieval chant work their way into the oddball ‘Love And A Yellow Rose’ although my money is on the Nilsson meets Paul McCartney jewel ‘Maple Fudge’. The slinky ‘We’re Coming To Dinner’ closes the album on a mediocre note and although ‘Wheatfield Soul’ is an uneven album there’s enough flashing lights to indicate this was a band going places.

In Summary

Worth seeking out is the Iconoclassic reissue which adds the trippy pre-LP single ‘When Friends Fall Out’, the bluesy ‘Guess Who Blues’ featuring red hot guitar from Bachman and the Otis Redding send-up ‘Of A Dropping Pin’.


These Eyes

These eyes - The Guess Who (1969)

Contact Us | Edit User Profile | Using a VPN

What is your rating for the album (music)?

Click on a star (click twice) to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this album..

Thanks for voting.

Follow us on social media!

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments